Is Natural Flea and Tick Repellent for dogs Effective?

Sharing is caring!

The Flea & Tick Prevention Dilemma

Each year I face the same dilemma: debating if I want to try a natural flea and tick repellent for dogs, and which one to use if I do. It’s not an easy decision – each choice involves risk for your dog.

Do you agonize over this too?

If you use conventional flea and tick products, you are either feeding your dog a potentially dangerous chemical or putting it on their skin.

That is worrisome, especially when you start hearing stories of dogs who experienced neurological problems such as seizures and nerve pain after receiving a flea and tick treatment.

On the flip side, if you don’t treat your dog and your dog gets lyme disease, they can experience a number of painful symptoms that can be hard to treat if the disease is not caught early. Additionally, ticks can also crawl from the dog onto their human family.

Confused person

WHAT TO DO???

Potential Dangers From Conventional Flea and Tick Treatments

In April of 2020, the FDA released a statement warning of dangers from numerous flea and tick medications, citing adverse events such as muscle tremors, ataxia, and seizures.

This fact sheet about the adverse effects of a number of flea and tick medications summarizes the FDA’s concerns and the medications that are involved.

Suffice it to say, if the FDA has to release an “alert” about it, it probably is not a good thing to use on your pet. Even if your pet doesn’t have these extreme reactions, there is no way of knowing what the toxins that these medications contain might do to your dog’s long term physical and mental health.

Can a Natural Flea and Tick Repellent for Dogs Really Work?

After my first summer of using 100% natural flea and tick prevention for dogs, I can answer with a confident YES – it works!

It takes a little while to get into a routine of putting the natural flea and tick repellent on your pet each day, but once you establish the habit it’s no big deal.

Some people choose to spray their dog with their natural flea and tick repellent first thing in the morning, reapplying if needed.

I choose to spray my dogs before our daily walks, as that is when they get 99% of their ticks. Also, if my dog stays out in the yard during the day to lie down and soak up the sunshine, I would spray their feet and bellies at that time.

Top Natural Products I Found

After doing a fair amount of research, I chose the following 3 products:

Earth Animal Flea & Tick Powder

Earth Animal Flea & Tick Powder

The first product is a dietary additive.  Earth Animal Flea & Tick Powder contains ingredients such as Brewer’s dried yeast and dried garlic.

The idea is that it produces a body scent that fleas and ticks don’t like. Based on my experience of how a strong garlic meal “modifies” my husband’s scent (and I’m talking scent in a 3-5 foot radius here . . . !), I thought this idea had great potential and added it to my dog’s breakfast each day.

The second product I use is a cedarwood essential oil spray. Each day before our walks, I spray my dogs lightly, especially their paws, legs, and bellies .

I chose Paws & Claws dog spray because it had only one essential oil vs. a mix. With a dog that reacts behaviorally to food and non-food products, the simpler I keep it the less risk he’ll turn into Cujo. 

Paws & Claws contains 10% cedarwood oil, which not only repels fleas and ticks but actually kills them if they get sprayed. I chose it because it contains a higher percentage cedarwood oil than Wondercide (a similar product).

Bonus feature: cedarwood oil is known to “defuse anger, reduce fear, aggression, anxiety and nervousness, helps us to see situations objectively.” I read that and it was like ,,, SOLD! – to the lady with the fearful nervous reactive dog that needs flea and tick prevention.

vets best flea and tick home spray
Vets Best Flea & Tick Spray

I use Vet’s Best Flea and Tick Spray if I find a random flea on one of my dogs. This doesn’t happen often (every few years), and generally only happens if the dog has a low immune system for other reasons.

I have also used it on fosters who come in with fleas, they usually get a chemical treatment before their transport to me but I spray them with this for the first week and rub it in just in case any eggs hatch.

The smell is actually lovely (in reference, the Paws & Claws cedarwood is a little strong, not bad, but strong). Vet’s Best has a clove peppermint scent that is pleasing to be around.

I haven’t tried this spray as a daily tick repellent so can’t attest to it’s functionality for that purpose.

DIY Natural Flea and Tick Repellent Recipe

Cedarwood, Geranium, and Lavender Essential Oil Spray

Pin the recipe below to save and share with friends!

Cedarwood essential oil is a great options for DIY flea and tick repellent sprays as well; it is safe for pets and humans while repelling and killing ticks & fleas.

For those of you who like to know the science behind the product, cedarwood oil apparently kills ticks in 6 different ways: dehydration, neutralization of body fluids, emulsification and encapsulation of body fats, suffocation, pheromonal (chemical signal) interference, and dissolving flea and tick larvae.

Virginian Cedarwood Oil is known to be more effective than other varieties against ticks, so be mindful of which type you are buying.

Geranium oil is known for its tick repelling properties; one study even found that geranium oil was just as effective at keeping ticks away as DEET.

Lavender essential oil is yet another oil shown in studies to repel ticks at a level comparable to DEET.

Instructions for Safely Applying Essential Oil Sprays

Never spray a product, natural or otherwise, on your dog’s face. Instead, spray the oil mix on your hands and gently rub it around your dog’s head, carefully avoiding their eyes and mouth.

After you have sprayed your dogs body, rub the oil in with your hands for better coverage.

If you prefer not to get the oil smell on your hands you don’t have to rub it into your dog’s body. I usually don’t and just make sure to spray thoroughly.

My Experience: Did Natural Flea and Tick Repellent for Dogs Really Work??

My summer experiment trying natural flea and tick repellent for my dogs was a resounding success! If I used the Paws and Claws cedarwood oil spray before my walks, my dogs were tick free.

Here are the key things I learned:

  • The Earth Animal food powder did not seem to be enough by itself to keep the dogs tick free. If I forgot the cedarwood oil spray, I would sometimes find a tick on my dog later that day. I do think, however, that without the food powder I would have found more ticks on the days I forgot to spray.
  • When I sprayed with the cedarwood oil spray before our walks (and before any prolonged time sitting in the yard), my dogs remained tick-free.

Next summer I will probably just use the cedarwood oil. I’ve gotten much better at remembering to put it on each day and that was the key to my success.

No ticks sign

It’s Time to Give Natural Flea and Tick Prevention for Dogs a Try

I’m pumped that this worked so well for my dogs. One whole summer, fewer ticks than I removed while using Frontline the year before, and no chemicals on my dogs =WIN!

What has worked for you, and what hasn’t? Put your story in the comments below so we can all learn from each other’s trial and error experiences.

Bonus: Did you know there are also natural ways to deworm dogs as well? Click and read to learn more.

Naturally,

Karen

**note: this post contains affiliate links. No one paid me to recommend these products, I recommend them because I like them. However, using the link to buy the products helps support happynaturaldog.com!**

Check Out These Related Posts!

Karen Pedersen Written by:

Karen is an independent copywriter who loves dogs and everything about them. She is married to Scott, has 4 kids, and likes to take a natural and holistic approach to living and pet ownership.

2 Comments

  1. Katy
    October 10, 2019
    Reply

    I use Wondercide and have found it to be effective. However, I was at the vet a couple days ago for an issue with my dogs eye they said it’s either an infection or demodex mange (something the rescues papers said he had previously). They recommended a flea and tick medication (Nexgard) to treat the mange (it kills mange mites not just fleas and ticks). I found this interesting as the eye issue began shortly after I adopted him and switched to an all natural flea and tick spray. I looked for all natural treatments for demodex mange and found very few options and almost none I could do right next to his eye. (I will be switching to a homeopathic vet)

    • October 11, 2019
      Reply

      You are right on point taking your dog to a holistic vet to find the best approach for this one. In addition, the holistic vet may be able to tell you whether you should be treating an infection or mange – it would be a bummer to use Nexgard and then find out it was an infection that needed a totally different treatment approach.

      I do know that demodectic mange is a sign of a low immune system. Normal dogs have the mites that cause demodectic mange on their skin, but a healthy immune system keeps them in check (similar to yeast in humans). So regardless of how you treat the mange (if you determine that is what you want to treat), you will also need to work with the holistic vet to come up with a plan to strengthen your dog’s immune system. A big part of this is probiotics. If you aren’t feeding one now, one that was recommended to me by Elaine Reinhardt, nutritional consultant at Reinhardt Ranch Holistic Nutrition Center for Pets in Elk Grove, California, is RX Biotic, by RX Vitamins.

      Let us know how things turn out!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Signup to receive new blog notifications